| Platinum | Arsenal City Tavern |
| Gold | Swifty's Restaurant & Pub |
| Silver | Valente's Restaurant |
| Bronze | Athos Restaurant |
| Bronze | Dan's 2 |
| Top Pick | Angelo's 677 Prime |
| Top Pick | Atomic Wings |
| Top Pick | Belt Line 3 |
| Top Pick | Delmonico's Italian Steakhouse |
| Top Pick | Jack's Oyster House |