| Platinum | Perreca’s Bakery |
| Gold | Stewart's Shops |
| Silver | Peaches Cafe |
| Bronze | Dunkin' |
| Top Pick | Cafe Madison |
| Top Pick | Cafe One Eleven |
| Top Pick | Gong Cha Albany |
| Top Pick | Jacob Alejandro |
| Top Pick | Motor Oil Coffee |
| Top Pick | Stack's Espresso Bar |
| Stagecoach Coffee |