| Platinum | Allie B's Cozy Kitchen |
| Gold | Arsenal City Tavern |
| Silver | The City Beer Hall |
| Bronze | Gateway Diner |
| Top Pick | Ale & Oyster |
| Top Pick | Cafe Madison |
| Top Pick | dp An American Brasserie |
| Top Pick | Joe's Tavern |
| Top Pick | Lost and Found Bar and Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Swifty's Restaurant & Pub |