| Platinum | Bella-Napoli Italian Bakery |
| Gold | Perreca’s Bakery |
| Silver | Dunkin' |
| Bronze | Fiorello Bakery & Deli |
| Top Pick | Bake For You |
| Top Pick | Bitchin Donuts |
| Top Pick | Nothing Bundt Cakes |
| Top Pick | Nyx; A Scratch Baking Co. |
| Top Pick | Smith's Orchard |
| Top Pick | Zachary's Pastry Shop |